I've done some shopping in between working on the museum's ambitious winter projects. The big find was enough plastic lenses to equip all of the 18" ceiling light fixtures. I also found brackets for a right-side cut lever for one end.
Adlake's owner and a sales rep were there. I was glad to hear that the new ownership wants to work with museums and car owners. Rather than requiring a minimum order, they will sell single units. They also offer a refurbish/rebuild service for existing hardware. I'm also told their website now has a password-protected members section. Members may order repair parts like springs directly from Adlake. Their foundry is intact and they are willing to cast the occasional repair part if needed - their sales rep told me they have a lot of the old patterns in a (my guess) 200 sq. ft. pattern room. They also have a good fabric curtain business. On the unfortunate side, previous owners sold the aluminum window sash business and razed the buildings. They've contemplated trying to re-enter that business. Let's wish them luck.
Gateway Rail Services, Inc. was there. They purchased the assets of the former Illinois Transit Assembly Corp near St Louis. Of most interest to me, they replicated the aluminum extrusion needed to make "Adlake" window sash.
UTC RAS Rail Systems Group had a booth. They are an AAR M-1003 / ISO 9002 wheel, bearing, truck and transmission shop. To me, they're a new vendor.
During our tour of Amtrak's Beech Grove shop they indicated that their services are now available to car owners. Beech Grove is, of course, a full-service shop.
Ozark Rail Logistics / Batavia and Ohio Railway Services were there. I picked up their brochures and added them to the "see also" section.
AcoustiBlok sent samples of their 1/8" closed-cell rubber acoustical insulation.
Delval Rail Car had a booth. Another new vendor (to me,) they offer many of the engineering, heavy work, and Amtrak compliance services I could use right now. I was not able to talk to them.
Last weekend a little incident got me thinking. I had a three-axle truck half-suspended in the air while two helpers on the ground put wood blocking under it. I noticed one helper - a young newbie - running to be in the right position. That bothered me so I asked him to slow down. Mulling it over, a lesson I have learned is: "Don't hurry it. Hurry is when stupid happens." Whether I'm machining, welding, or doing layout, I do my best work when I'm relaxed. If I'm pushing too fast, or stressed, or had too much coffee - that's when it helps to slow down, take a breath, relax, and focus.
I received word from Starfire that the side sill engineering is in progress. I'm definitely looking forward to seeing it.
In March I was occupied with a wheel set replacement for the museum.
1146 is inside the shop until October. Since the side sill engineering was in-progress, I decided to start working on Body End Sill replacement.
Starfire shipped the side sill drawings on May 5th. Look near the bottom under "Side Sill Structural"
I took a week of vacation in May to work on 1146, and hired Matt Arnold to help. The pictures follow:
| The reason for removing the stainless cap was installation of temporary bracing, to keep the side sills from wandering off while I replace the end sills. Note the shim needed to make sure the brace is bearing on the end casting. | |
| The stainless cap covered openings in the draft gear pocket area of the end casting, which stretches from the body bolster to the coupler pocket. | |
| I lowered the camera through the middle opening in the end casting and photographed the truck's locking center pin. Look at that huge pile of dirt. | |
| Looking the opposite direction, in the foreground is the yoke around the draft gear. Farther way is one of the many pivots in the drawbar. | |
| This view is down and angled toward the coupler. We are looking at the butt end of the yoke around the draft gear. The draft gear itself is layers of steel and rubber, with thick steel blocks at the ends. The end axle is visible through the bottom opening. | |
| Looking down at the rubber-and-steel draft gear pack. The yoke is in the foreground and the rest is end casting. | |
| I spied this in a woodworker's store in West Des Moines. It's a precision T-Square with a very wide foot (left, vertical in picture) and closely-spaced holes for a pencil. It looks to me like a quick way to scribe a straight line precisely aligned with the bottom of the side sheet - useful for side sill replacement, since the replacement sheet would not have to be fitted for a consistently-spaced joint. | |
| Another option in the same store. This one should go faster, but may be less accurate. | |
| Here's the tech info on the next spool of welding wire, which I just installed. | |
| Mike welds in the temporary side sill brace. Yes, it has a very deep cross-section. Overkill? Probably. It was lying around without a purpose... | |
| I used four welds on each end of the brace. Enough to hold it, but easily cut with a 4.5" cut-off wheel and snapped off for quick removal. | |
| I learned this trick from Matt Arnold: Cut the rivet heads with a cut-off wheel and finish grinding with a 1/4" wheel. It's much faster than grinding the entire head to dust. Two grinders makes it even faster. | |
| The Rivet Buster made quick work of the rivets. The body end sill is a W-shaped 1/4" piece and an L-channel. I only need to replace the former. | |
| I'll need to retain the hole in the end sill for the pipe to the Conductor's emergency brake valve. | |
| Sometimes the 4.5" grinder cut-off wheel snags, and then the nut is so tight the spanner wrench bends and/or the stop pin in the aluminum head is damaged. The solution is to break off as much of the wheel as possible with a Vise Grip, and then use a box wrench and a slip-jaw pliers to loosen it. | |
| One last look at the vestibule door hinges which did not come off easily. The upper pair on each side came nicely, the lower did not. Some of these will be destroyed in removal. I have new ones, but they don't have the decorative balls top and bottom. | |
| Here's the BL corner of the body after hinge removal. I was able to remove the screws with a Vise Grip. Note the layers above the hinge: Body End Sheet, Corner Post (outer section) with offset to clear the body end sheet, and extruded aluminum door trim. The mess below is part of the GN fixed step modification. Part of the end sill is already gone. | |
| Now the aluminum trim is off. Note the shim which ACF installed under the trim at the bottom only. Presumably the door posts were not parallel so they adjusted. My reason for notching the body end sill is clear: Access to remove rivet heads on the body end post. | |
| Part of the side sheet and part of the outer section of the body corner are removed. The middle section of the body corner is visible (with the rust perforation in it) as is the inner section (the fabricated U-channel at the right.) The middle is a modified side wall post, and the inner a modified end wall post. | |
| Another view of the body BL corner. One can see how the end sill fits into the side sill Z-channel, and how the corner post sits on the side sill only. The skirt end piece is attached only to the end sill. At top, what looks like a buck-toothed gap is actually body end sheet (right) and a tapping plate for door trim screws (left). | |
| As Matt removed the side sheet, he noticed the bottom edge of the sheet did not follow the side sill Z-channel. The Z-channel loops up over the bolster. | |
| We put my twenty-foot cold-rolled straight edge along the side sill to illustrate it's not so straight-and-true nature. We also decided to jack this corner just a hair - working against another jack on the body BR corner. | |
| Same subject, different camera angle. Matt did more measuring later and determined the side sill Z-channel loops over both bolsters and sags in the middle and at the ends. | |
| The body BR end sill has been removed. Note the corner is supported by a jack in addition to the temporary beam bridging the two side sills. There is another jack on the body BR corner. | |
| Without the end sill, the BL end of the side sill is more plainly seen. I left the support/closure for the outer end of the end sill, as well as the inner C-channel which the splash pan is welded to. | |
| Opposite, here is the support/closure for the inner end of the end sill, which ACF welded to the end casting. | |
| ACF drawing 4675130 dimensions the body end sills. I had Linder's Specialty fabricate them according to the drawing, and I cut the BL sill according to the drawing. It fit perfectly. The track jack is for shoving the end post out of the way. | |
| The new end sill is clamped in and ready to tack. It looked a little crooked, but measuring off the ceiling (there is a major beam across the width) showed that it was right or even 1/16th high at the outer end. Considering the jack pushing up, I thought that was OK. | |
| The new end sill was welded to the center casting using the same procedure as the hand brake chain sheave below it: Locally heat the casting to at least 150 degrees Fahrenheit, and keep it above that temperature while welding. Then needle-scale the weld while hot for some measure of stress relief. | |
| Detail of the end sill weld to the side sill. Yes, overhead is more difficult to make look nice. | |
| Here's a detail of the end sill weld to the outer support. The dark spots in the weld are where it was tacked. The odd piece at right is merely to fill a gap. | |
| Same area, on the underside. | |
| Detail of the underside weld to the inboard support. | |
| Detail of the underside weld to the end casting. This was a difficult position, as I was inside the truck leaning over its end transom. | |
| Meanwhile, Matt had completed the 4" discovery pass of the side sheet removal, marked it up with the 12" cut line and positions of all the vertical sheet stiffener angles, and begun sheet removal. This is the beginning of the side sill replacement. | |
| After welding the body end wall post on, I attached the new inner section of the door post. Both leave about a 1/4" gap at the bottom and do not touch the flat of the end sill. The outer section of the door post will go on after the end sheet. | |
| Matt quickly settled on this technique: First he cut along the 12" mark with a cut-off wheel in a 4 1/2" angle grinder. Between the verticals he cut through, but at the verticals he did not, to avoid nicking them. Then he cut midway between with a plasma cutting torch. (Miller Spectrum Extreme 375 - small but gutsy.) In the opened-up coach section we used a steel spark shield to control the hot spray. | |
| The body end sheet needs tapping plates for the end platform and the trap door hinge. I had extra material from the end platform sides so used it. All the clamps and bars are to align it before welding. | |
| Matt has pretty much finished opening up the left side in the coach area. | |
| The rest of Matt's technique was using a heavy hammer to drive a chisel between the vertical and the side sheet, breaking the welds without deforming the vertical channel. | |
| Here's the extreme rust on the right side sill, where the side sheet had perforated under the dining room windows. | |
| Matt had never seen an ACF Cor-Ten side sill this bad, so he wanted me to document the exterior evidence. One tell-tale was that the spot welds along the bottom edge had been ripped apart by the build-up of rust. | |
| Another tell-tale was that rust between the side sheet and the verticals & bottom edge had consistently bent the bottom edge of the side sheet. | |
| This is stunning: A 1/4" angle and a 3/8" zee produced almost a 2" pile of rust. (Not long after taking this photo, we all had great fun pulling out huge chunks.) | |
| Cross-section of the right-side door post, showing the tapping plate in the hinge area. Overall it's a little warped from being pounded off, and part of the cross-section is missing at the upper right. | |
| I've just removed the right-side door post. I thought it would look better if the cuts were symmetrical, but the left cut fell right in the hinge so I went higher. The left will have to be adjusted. Interesting details to notice are the the footprints of the end platform and of the trap door hinge, the square opening for the trap door light switch, and the horizontal weld line where the GN patched the body end while changing from roll-up steps to fixed. | |
| The end sheet is gone - removed in pieces with a cut-off wheel - and the horizontal angles on the end sill have been cut with the plasma cutting torch. I don't find the angles on the ACF diagrams, so I assume they're part of the GN's step modifications. I kept one rivet from the door post for matching the look with pan-head screws or Huck bolts or other fasteners. | |
| Angles and trap door hinge tapping plate removed. I've also opened a window for access to cut wall post rivet heads off with the cut-off wheel. Remains of the roll-up step's pivot bracing are visible through the window. | |
| This is how it looked at the end of my work week. Another week is planned for July. |
One slight change in plans: Rather than replacing the left side sill this year and the right next year, Matt and I decided it would be better to prep both this year and replace both next year. That decision is driven by the need to jack the entire car into alignment. By doing both at once, it is only necessary to align everything once.
I have met several people who worked in the dining cars of both the Great Northern and the Northern Pacific, but in May I had the great fortune of interviewing someone who actually worked in my car. Click here to read a transcript.
Here is an abrasive selection chart for blast media which I found at a local supplier. I like that it shows the surface finish produced in mils, which is how paint vendors write their specs, and that it gives tips on what purpose each media is suited for.
Another random find: A chart of brake cylinder pressures in full service and emergency at different locomotive feed valve settings. This assumes the 2.5:1 ratio on a freight car with perfect piston travel, but is also great for passenger cars with dummy volumes instead of a single body-mounted brake cylinder, and a relay valve to drive the brake cylinder(s) according to the resulting reference pressure. This is pure gold when converting a passenger car to a newer style of brake valves, both for design and for testing afterwards. It stops at 90 psi, but one should be able to extrapolate to Amtrak's 110 psi trainline.
In July I was able to take another week to work on 1146, and again Matt Arnold was available to help.
I stumbled across an alert in Tools of the Trade's Industry News newsletter that a new EPA rule is making lead paint more difficult. A little investigating led me to the EPA website on lead. I haven't fully investigated - thankfully 1146 had been sandblasted and primed before I bought it.
In August, a friend and I had a few nights and weekends to do sand blasting.
Discussion on the Yahoo! Passenger Car List newsgroup on August 16th and 17th led me to photographs of the Great Northern's "International" in the City of Vancouver Archives. In the photos was Great Northern's Pendulum car 999. It was an interesting diversion. 999 was almost an experimental prototype - almost a sales sample - which never took off. The May 20th, 1940 issue of Life magazine reveals that Cortland Hill, grandson of James J. Hill, was a backer of the development effort. It ran frequently in the International with 1146.
Another set of records in the City of Vancouver Archives documents the abandonment of the Great Northern's passenger station in 1962. This was 1146's northern port of call.
Searching for parts for the museum's caboose CB&Q 13500, I discovered this vendor: Comet Industries, Inc. Their parts catalog intested me most, but they have other products and services such as AEI tag programming. Some of the parts turned out to be used (side bearings) but they worked.
Andy;
Question for you: I am rebuilding the door threshold from the vestibule platform into the car. I'm working according to the original blueprints, except that I'm welding rather than riveting. I would like to weld all around, to seal out water, but am questioning whether that will weaken the end casting.
This drawing is useful: http://www.erixrailcar.com/history/ACF_Blueprints/6674939.pdf
Here's a detail from that drawing. The red arrows show where I propose continuous welds across the top of the casting to seal out water. (This drawing makes it look like there were welds originally, but so little of the .090" L.A.H.T. was left that I cannot tell.) I would, as you recommended last year, preheat the casting above 150 degrees f.
Would you be able to give your opinion by the end of the week? I'm working against a deadline.
Eric
Eric:
I see no problem with seal welding as you propose, with the indicated preheat, as the weld locations are outboard of the draft lugs and are therefore in a lower stress location on the casting. Along with preheat, be careful to properly terminate the welds, and form the beads uniformly, avoiding cratering.
Andrew J. Spurlock, P.E.
The Streamliner Memories website posted two interesting articles, one on the Steamlined Internationals, and one on the very unusual Pendulum car which called the Seattle-based trains home.
For my third and last week of vacation working on 1146, Mom and Dad came up to help.
The BL corner was sprayed with Shale Grey DuPont Corlar 2.1ST. All other raw steel got the mineral red Rust-Oleum.
Here is where the original home of 1146's electrical cabinet ended up: The Aberdeen, Carolina & Western. Look for SP 100 "Airslie".
I didn't get pictures: After mounting the hand brake support plate for the last time, I caulked around the edge with 3M Automotive Seam Sealant to prevent rust between it, the collision post, and the end sheet.
Once the insulation was out, I got my first really good look at the side sills. To document, I started at vestibule opposite the hand brake and went around the entire car taking pictures as I went, ending at the hand brake. Click here to see the entire sequence.